How to Test Your Headlines for Better Engagement

Engagement is the lifeblood of digital content, and it all starts with a compelling headline.

How to Test Your Headlines for Better Engagement

Engagement is the lifeblood of digital content, and it all starts with a compelling headline.

But how can you ensure your headline sparks curiosity and invites clicks?

Welcome to your essential guide on ‘how to test your headlines for better engagement.’

Strap in as we delve into proven strategies and techniques that promise to transform your headline creation process, maximize your click-through rates, and boost overall reader engagement.

Let’s get those headlines working harder for you

“80% of people will read your headlines, but only 20% will go on to finish the article.”

What are the key elements of an engaging headline?

Headlines, they’re the gatekeepers to your content.

They’re what draw readers in or push them away.

You might have great content, but with a headline that pops, only some will make it past the first line.

But what makes a headline engaging?

First, it’s got to be catchy. It’s got to grab the reader by the lapels and pull them in.

That usually means it should be snappy and to the point.

Then, there’s intrigue. A sense of mystery that makes the reader need to find out more.

Finally, it’s got to deliver on its promise. Having a catchy headline that doesn’t match the content is no use. That’s a surefire way to lose trust.

So, how do we test for these things?

First, we can use the “4 U’s” test. This test checks if a headline is Useful, Unique, Ultra-specific, and Urgent.

This test can help ensure your headline has the key ingredients to drive engagement.

Second, you can use A/B testing. You can see which headlines perform better by presenting two different headlines to different groups.

“The difference between a click and a scroll often lies in a headline.”

These are just a few methods you can use to test your headlines. For a deeper dive into the psychology of compelling headlines, check out this post on anchoring bias.

How can I use data to improve my headline performance?

Data, it’s the bedrock of any solid marketing strategy. You can always tune your headlines with the correct data to hit the sweet spot. But the question remains, how do we collect and use that data?

First off, you’ll want to look at click-through rates. This is the percentage of people who click on your headline versus the number of people who see it.

“Using numbers in your headlines can lead to a 20% increase in click-through rates. “

This gives you a direct measure of how engaging your headline is.

Next, look at dwell time. That’s how long someone stays on your page after clicking your headline. This can tell you if your headline and content are well-aligned.

Another metric to consider is social shares.

If people are sharing your content, it means your headline is engaging and compelling enough to share with others.

The trick here is to keep testing. Try different headlines and track these metrics. Over time, you’ll see what works and what doesn’t.

For a more in-depth look at how data can enhance your headline performance, check out this piece on effective SEO audits.

What tools can I use to test my headlines?

A whole suite of tools is out there to help you craft and test the perfect headline. Let’s take a look at a few.

First up, there’s CoSchedule’s Headline Analyzer. This tool rates your headline based on various factors, including word balance, length, sentiment, and keyword inclusion.

Then there’s Advanced Marketing Institute’s Headline Analyzer. This one scores your headline based on emotional marketing value. It aims to assess how your headline connects emotionally with your audience.

Lastly, we have Sharethrough’s Headline Analyzer. This tool gives your headline a quality score and provides suggestions for improvement.

Each of these tools offers a different perspective on your headline’s effectiveness. Use them in combination for a well-rounded approach to headline testing.

For more tools to up your copywriting game, check out this list of SEO tools.

How can I craft a headline that appeals to my target audience?

Knowing your audience is half the battle in crafting compelling headlines. It’s not just about being catchy — it’s about resonating with your readers on a deep level.

But how can you achieve this?

Firstly, consider your audience’s needs. What problem does your content solve for them? A headline that promises to solve a problem is incredibly compelling.

Secondly, think about their values. What matters to them?

If you can tie your content to your audience’s values, your headline will instantly be more appealing.

Lastly, use the language they use. If your audience uses specific jargon, include it in your headline. It’ll make them feel seen and understood.

Testing these elements can be as simple as conducting surveys or as complex as analyzing social media trends. The key is to keep your audience at the center of your testing process.

For a deep dive into understanding your audience, check out this piece on Maslow’s hierarchy.

How can I use emotional triggers in my headlines?

Ah, emotions. Whether we realize it or not, they’re the driving force behind our decisions.

Tapping into these emotions can drastically improve your headline engagement as a marketer.

But how?

Firstly, identify the emotions you want to trigger. Is it curiosity? Fear of missing out? A desire for social status?

Next, craft your headline in a way that triggers this emotion. This could mean using certain words, creating a sense of urgency, or making a bold promise.

Remember, though, authenticity is vital.

Don’t try to manipulate your audience with false promises or exaggerated claims. This will only backfire in the long run.

To learn more about using emotional triggers effectively, look at this post on emotional triggers that drive purchases.

How important is headline length in engagement?

Headline length, it’s a hot topic in the world of copywriting. Some swear by short and sweet, while others advocate for longer, more descriptive headlines.

So, what’s the deal?

Well, research suggests that headlines with 6–7 words perform best.

They’re long enough to convey sufficient information but short enough to keep attention.

However, this is a relatively easy and fast rule. Depending on your platform and audience, different lengths perform better.

The key here is to test. Use different lengths and see which performs best with your audience. Remember to keep track of your results to inform future headline creation.

Want to know more about crafting long-form content that keeps readers engaged? Take a look at this article on how long-form content can boost conversions.

How can I use SEO in my headlines to improve engagement?

SEO, it’s a magic word in digital marketing. Done right, it can bring your content in front of the right eyes at the right time. But how does it factor into headlines?

Using relevant keywords in your headlines can boost their visibility in search results. This means more people see your headline, and more clicks ensue.

However, don’t shoehorn keywords in at the expense of readability. Your headline still needs to be engaging and make sense to your reader.

Furthermore, Google’s algorithms are intelligent. They’re looking for quality, relevant content. So, make sure your headline accurately reflects your content.

For a comprehensive look at SEO in copywriting, check out this piece on SEO tools to improve copywriting.

How can I make my headlines more engaging with personalization?

Personalization, it’s a powerful tool in any marketer’s toolkit. It helps readers feel seen and understood, which can drastically boost engagement.

But how can you personalize headlines?

If you’re sending emails or push notifications, you can include the reader’s name in the headline.

Studies have shown this can significantly increase click-through rates.

In other cases, you can use data to understand your audience’s wants and tailor your headlines to their interests.

However, tread carefully with personalization. While it can be effective, it can also be creepy if done excessively or incorrectly.

Want to know more about personalization in marketing? Check out this piece on personalization in email copywriting.

How can scarcity impact headline engagement?

Scarcity, it’s a potent psychological trigger. The fear of missing out can drive us to take action, which also applies to headlines.

You can create a sense of scarcity in your headlines by suggesting a limited quantity or time frame.

This could be a limited number of products, a closing window for registration, or an ending sale.

However, just like emotional triggers, it’s essential to use scarcity authentically.

Claim scarcity only if it exists, as this can lead to lost trust.

To dive deeper into scarcity in marketing, check out this article on scarcity in email marketing campaigns.

How can I continue to improve my headlines over time?

Improvement, it’s a never-ending journey, especially in the world of digital marketing.

Staying on top of your headline game with trends changing and evolving algorithms is critical.

So, how do you continue to improve?

The answer is simple: Test, learn, iterate.

Try new things. Use the tools at your disposal. Listen to your audience. Keep an eye on the latest trends.

As you continue to test and learn, you’ll inevitably get better. And with every tweak, every adjustment, you’ll inch closer to the perfect headline.

The road to improvement may be long, but the destination is worth the journey. Good luck!

Kerry, a seasoned copywriter and digital marketing strategist, brought this article to you. Were you looking to improve your marketing game? Check out more insights on

Originally published at on August 2, 2023.

Subscribe to Kerry Morrison

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.